DVD Audio Deficiencies
By Craig Fuqua
Fans of the classic "Jonny Quest" series (ABC, 1964-65)
were disappointed to find out that several lines of dialog
had been censored from the May 11, 2004, Warner DVD set.
(c) 2004 We're presenting them so our readers can hear what they're missing and judge for themselves whether the edits were appropriate for a home video release for a 2004 audience. |
| Pursuit of the Po-Ho | |
|---|---|
|
In this episode, Race swims up to the Po-Ho village
and delivers a warning to the Indians that includes the insults,
"ignorant savages" and "heathen monkeys."
Those phrases have been deleted from the DVD's English and Spanish audio
tracks, but not from the subtitles.
The splash sound effect when Race pops out of the water is also gone, but it's been missing from Turner station broadcasts since 2000 (and maybe earlier). The section as it was originally heard: PoHoUneditedSection.mp3 (595K MP3, 25 seconds) For some reason, the episode title card is silent on both "Pursuit of the Po-Ho" and "The Curse of Anubis." That's not how those stories were first heard, so the flaw must be in the prints. Listen to the distinctive title card underscore here: PoHoMissingTitleCardMusic.mp3 (166K MP3, 7 seconds) |
|
Here are the individual elements in a DVD-compatible WAV-format (for
best results, save them to your hard drive):
PoHoMissingTitleCardMusic.wav (1.3 meg, 7 seconds, corresponding to 1:31.061 to 1:38.095 in the full English audio track) PoHoMissingSplash.wav (541K, 3 seconds, corresponding to 16:01.794 to 16:04.676) PoHoMissingIgnorantSavages.wav (608K, 3 seconds, corresponding to 16:17.439 to 16:20.676) PoHoMissingHeathenMonkeys.wav (523K, 3 seconds, corresponding to 16:22.752 to 16:25.538) |
|
| Monster in the Monastery | |
|---|---|
|
In this episode, the leader of the Yeti-disguised bad guys shoots
at Jonny from a stone staircase. Jonny fires arrows to burst oil
bags above him, causing the leader to fall down the steps and plummet
off the mountain to his death. The DVD is missing Jonny's joke as
the man rolls toward him, "Uh-oh. Here comes the Oriental Express."
The line has also been taken out of the subtitles.
The section as it was originally heard: MonasteryMissingOrientalExpress.mp3 (271K MP3, 11 seconds) The DVD also immortalizes a puzzling insert into this story that also appears in the early 1990s VHS release of this title. On these versions, right before the Yeti leader unmasks himself, we hear a Bandit growl, an unidentified sound effect, and Jonny says, "Quiet, boy." This didn't exist on the original broadcast. The insertion also pushes Hadji's line, "Hey, what's he doing?" back several seconds, resulting in his lip moving but no sound coming out. This is what you hear on the DVD and VHS: MonasteryExtraDialog.mp3 (206K MP3, 8 seconds) Here's the original version: MonasteryComparisonToExtraDialog.mp3 (194K MP3, 8 seconds) Both clips start with Hadji's line, "Carrying a lamp?," and end with the sound of the Yeti removing his mask. |
|
Here are the individual elements in a DVD-compatible WAV-format (for
best results, save them to your hard drive):
MonasteryMissingOrientalExpress.wav (2.1 meg, 11.5 seconds, corresponding to 16:38.534 to 16:50.025 in the full English audio track) MonasteryMinusExtraDialog.wav (1.3 meg, 7 seconds, corresponding to 10:27.041 to 10:34.115) |
|
|
Note: If you listen to the DVD where the dialog has been removed
and compare it to the unedited version here, you'll notice that the
music and sound effects are unaffected by the edits. This means that
either the original music/effects tracks for these episodes has
survived the past 40 years or that the censors were able to reproduce
the background audio from other sources.
It's clear from listening to the Spanish versions that separate background audio tracks were created for translation purposes. |
|
Jonny Quest and distinctive likenesses © Hanna-Barbera. All other images, image designs and other image work on this site are © ClassicJQ.com, © Hanna-Barbera or as noted. Text content is © ClassicJQ.com, except where noted otherwise, and may not be shared or re-published without the consent of the author. This is strictly a fan-based site, and is in no way affiliated with or approved by Hanna-Barbera or any other organizations, unless specifically indicated otherwise. |